Today we're going to talk about Jund. Weird, I know, but I've been doing lots of Arena Standard as of late and I've got some conclusions to share. And decklists!
So if you were with me last time, this is where I entered into Ravnica Allegiances at. This is what I call the "District Jund" since it has District Guide. District Guide kind of messes some stuff up, notably, you need to play a lot of basic lands, while on its face, it would seem that the best way to build a manabase is just 4X of each shock and M10 land. You also might note that we've only got 23 land here, since between Seekers' Squire, Merfolk Branchwalker, and District Guide, hitting land drops shouldn't be too much of a problem.
The virtual and actual card advantage gained by a low land count and lots of creatures that give you lands is somewhat negated by losing access to Memorial to Folly. We could play it, I just can't bring myself to do it. Not playing Memorial, though, makes it so all of our lands enter untapped pretty much all the time, which is very nice.
One card I've been high on lately is Thrashing Brontodon. Wilderness Reclamation scares me, and it also happens to be fantastic against the Red decks and the White aggro decks, since it both gums up the ground very effectively early and kills their good enchantments late. In addition to that, Search for Azcanta is always a problem that gets solved pretty cleanly with it, and its worst case scenario is just a three-mana 3/4, which isn't that bad anyways. That's the biggest reason why Jadelight Ranger is absent from most of these lists. Jadelight is great, but I want to play Brontodon when I can, and we don't really do the whole Wildgrowth Waker plan anyways.
Another thing with this deck is that the basic lands let you punish opposing Settle the Wreckage and Assassin's Trophy much better. Personally, I don't like Assassin's Trophy and giving my opponents extra mana, but I also play basic-light decks that often draw the one basic land and get punished for it. You don't really run into that here.
Out of the lists here, I think that this is the one with the most potential. The actual numbers here are pretty bad because I've spent most of my time
Also, what is up with those card prices?!? I think they're for Magic Online and they are the total for all the copies of that card, but wowza, Vivien is pretty pricey.
So here's a lot of the same stuff, except no District Guide. Memorial makes our long game a little better, but our early game is a little hampered by lands entering the battlefield tapped and maybe missing out on some fixing.
The big problem with having a late-game focused deck is that the late-game might not be a winnable fight against Hydroid Krasis. The way that I've been able to beat the Sultai decks is to wipe up their Wildgrowth Walker early game and then pressure them enough so that they have to cast Krasis before they want to. There's always a bigger fish. There's also merit to putting on some pressure against the control decks early to keep them off balance. Explore-guy plus District Guide might not require a sweeper, but it's certainly a noticeable clock, and you got to hit land drops out of the deal. This deck is still capable of presenting a quick clock but not as consistently.
The other thing is that this deck doesn't really even have extra mana to work with, so it's not like we're really running away with the game with our Siege-Gang Commanders and Biogenic Oozes. These two cards are really quite good, though. They gum up the ground and are pretty useful mana sinks in the late game. I'm not sure which one is better, they have different applications. The Ooze can tangle with Carnage Tyrants and get better as the game goes on. Siege-Gang is a little bit more of a defensive card but doesn't beat Carnage Tyrant as well. Untapping with either against a control opponent is usually game. The decider might be Goblin Chainwhirler: if the red deck becomes more popular in the Best of Three Arena Events, then I might swap to Ooze.
You'll also note that we cut Carnage Tyrant altogether here, except for one in the board. I think that eventually I'll end up doing that with the previous list as well. Carny Boy isn't all it's cracked up to be anymore, honestly. I think the format is a little bit more prepared for it, with Kaya's Wrath and and the Sultai nee Golgari lists can go over the top of it anyways. That wasn't the case before Hydroid Krasis, where if you were playing Memorials, Find/Finalities, and a bunch of Tyrants of your own, then you were on even footing with them. To be clear, Carnage Tyrant is a good card against the Sultai decks, but it might not fit the plan we need to be able to beat the midrange decks and have good game against everyone else. We are no longer Golgari plus red, we are differentiating ourselves more than that. You don't want to be a worse version of something else.
A couple of cards that I am really liking are Vraska, Golgari Queen and Angrath the Flame Chained. They are both long-game threats that are at worst removal spells for a big Wildgrowth Walker. A lot needs to go wrong for you to really get taken out by a Walker draw, including you not drawing removal and them having multiple Jadelight Rangers or Branchwalkers, but when that happens it's really hard to win. That's why I'm always glad to have extra ways to kill opposing Wildgrowth Walkers and take that element out of the game. These two planeswalkers do that and then some, helping turn the corner and create some late game advantage. Notably they both kill Hydroid Krasis as well, although when Krasis is an 8/8 or whatever, it's not actually the body that's important.
Dire Fleet Daredevil has been hit or miss. You can't always depend on your opponent to have cards that are good against themselves. Against Esper Control, for instance, if they don't have Thought Erasure, it's almost a blank. Similarly to Thrashing Brontodon, the fail state of a two mana 2/1 first striker isn't awful. Plus, Dire Fleet's best matchup might be the mirror match. Hitting an opposing copy of Find/Finality helps quite a lot, and any Cast Down or Vraska's Contempt replicates Ravenous Chupacabra very well, which is an effect you can't have too much of. A card that I'm interested in trying in its slot is Growth-Chamber Guardian, which is another mana sink-esque cheap creature.
I've worked on this deck the least of all so far. It's an attempt to get back to the Farseek/Thragtusk decks of RTR/Innistrad standard, where you had a mana ramp source that didn't depend on a creature surviving. Rejuvenator is no Farseek, but it is a 1/1 creature, which isn't insignificant. Your planeswalkers are far more likely to live if they come down a turn earlier and have a 1/1 chump blocker for them. The problem is getting them to resolve, which doesn't always happen.
See, what makes a deck like this work is that you load up with cheap removal and expensive haymakers, then have a light ramp element to help fix and facilitate the late game. You try and keep up with aggressive decks until you get enough mana to start slamming big stuff. Against control opponents, that strategy doesn't work well at all, and you need to let your sideboard do lots of heavy lifting. Even still, the way to win those games isn't necessarily to board in Duress. You're threat light because you have ramp spells. You need to be taking two or more cards with you every time you cast a business spell. In the past that meant things like Rakdos's Return, Thragtusk, Huntmaster of the Fells, Garruk Primal Hunter. The cards we have available to us now don't seem like they quite can fit the roles in that plan as well. Also, in 2012, we never had to play against Teferi.
The other big problem for Jund in 2012 was Junk Reanimator (that now would be called Abzan Reanimator). They went way over the top of you and did the big value creature thing much better than you did, plus they had more mana dorks and beat you on that front too. But, Olivia Voldaren and Bonfire of the Damned were incredible against them, and we don't have that luxury in 2019. Find Finality is the closest thing to Bonfire of the Damned I can think of these days, and it pales in comparison, plus our version of the Junk Reanimator deck, Sultai, runs their own.
Without those tools, I don't think that a Jund deck can fight a long-game fight against Hydroid Krasis or Angel of Serenity or whatever there is for supermassive top-end. In fact, that's kind of the case for Black/Green strategies throughout all formats: Lingering Souls and Snapcaster Mage are fantastic in the Jund mirror in Modern, it's the other end of the spectrum that we're worried about when we play Red instead of Blue card advantage or White resiliency. The advantage comes from better, cheaper removal options and consistency that comes from having fewer moving parts.
I do like some of the flexibility you get from some of these cards though. Shivan Fire seems awesome when you have a bunch of mana available to you, but can't always expect to. Same goes for Carnival/Carnage, which is a card that I've been trying to squeeze into my decks and can never find the room. It doesn't really work as a sideboard card, but like I've said before, you have to have a really really good reason to play a non-creature in a Vivien Reid deck. Vivien is at its worst in this deck of any of the Jund lists I've tried, so there's another detractor for this plan.
Moving forward, I also want to try the Wildgrowth Walker package in one of these shells. It probably has to be the no-District Guide and no-Rejuvenator list, since I'm not sure Jadelight Ranger co-exists very well with those. I like not worrying about Wildgrowth Walker, since in a draw with no Explorers it is really, really bad, and drawing more than one Walker in that scenario is atrocious. Those are the kind of deckbuilding decisions I try to stay away from, where your cards are interdependent, but you still don't have any library manipulation or tutoring to fit the pieces together. Still, if the Chainwhirlers start to whirl their chains, it might be time to do some Explore shenanigans.
One last card I want to note is Incubation Druid, which I think is just a non-starter. Unlike Llanowar Elves, it has more late game capabilities and adds more than just green mana, which is super important. But costing two instead of one is huge of course, but also, just the fact that we depend on a creature's survival to get its payoff doesn't really work in this environment on such a killable creature. I really hate losing tempo in the early part of the game, which Llanowar Elves does not do when it dies to a Shock, but this does.
Thanks for reading, check out my Twitch channel for the slog that is Free to Play deck tuning, also go here for instagram, here for Twitter, and here for Youtube. See ya later!
No comments:
Post a Comment